I found Matsuda’s article on the division of labor in composition studies and ESL writing to be both informative and thought provoking. It was refreshing for me to read an article where the history of the discipline was laid out…
Classes
Parent for all the individual classes
Thoughts on Orientalism Reconsidered
by annacole1 • • 0 Comments
The Reading— Orientalism Reconsidered by Edward W. Said The Said reading was not my favorite one. My interest for Orientalism is waning. I thought this reading was going to be an account of rhetorical practices like the Xing Lu readings,…
Binary in Spivak
by annacole1 • • 0 Comments
The reading—-Rhetoric and Cultural Explanation: A Discussion with Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak In this interview of Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, I found it interesting that Spivak does not give an exact definition of Rhetoric when asked. Rhetoric in our modern time is…
Foucault
by Joel • • 4 Comments
Joel Manfredi Journal Entry “Panopticon” Dr. De Vries English 5870 In reading Michel Foucault’s “Panopticism,” I get a strong sense of the type of discipline that most teachers are looking for in their classrooms. It is, that…
bell hooks, “Rebel’s Dilemma,” commentary
by lmarik • • 1 Comment
In her short piece, “Rebel’s Dilemma,” bell hooks describes the balance between being an academic and a “rebel,” as she states the following: “Academia was where we worked but we wanted a life on the outside. We did not…
Orientalism
by Adam • • 1 Comment
Edward Said presents some interesting notions on the idea of Orientalism, as both a concept and as a field of study. Said’s concepts are similar to some of the readings we have done earlier in that he explains the difficulties…
Changing Bodies
by aarias1 • • 0 Comments
Changing Bodies Educational organizations are constantly looking at the establishment theory and practice. As Spivak associates conventions he states, “Rhetoric sees itself not as creating a balance between theory and practice, but rather as ‘inhabiting a kind of productive…
Spivak
by Mariana • • 1 Comment
I really liked what Spivak had to say about reconciliation between theory and practice ever happening. I too, feel that this is something that is impossible to achieve, especially when one considers that theory and practice depend on the culture…
Commentary Week 9
by tbell • • 1 Comment
Tina Bell English 5001 23 April 2009 Commentary Week 9 Paul Kei Matsuda published his article, “Composition Studies and ESL Writing: A Disciplinary Division of Labor,” in 1999, and the topic as to the best methods for teaching English as…
Commentary Week 10
by tbell • • 0 Comments
Tina Bell English 5001 23 April 2009 Commentary Week 10 “Rhetoric sees itself not as creating a balance between theory and practice, but rather as ‘inhabiting a kind of productive unease’” (1). Given Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak’s view of rhetoric, it…