Ramus sets out to debunk Quintillian’s claims by dissecting his work into more precise categories. He maintains that Quintillian intermingles rhetoric with other disciplines thus confusing its definition. For Ramus, an artist is defined only by the rules of his…
Classes
Parent for all the individual classes
Medieval Response
by Joel • • Comments Off
I am not sure I totally agree with Ramus’s point that scholars of rhetoric do not need a well balanced background in order to be good orators. In everyday life, I find that people who are smart in many areas…
Ramus vs. Vico: How Should Rhetoric be Taught?
by Anne Engert • • 0 Comments
Of what exactly should a curriculum in rhetoric consist? In “Arguments in Rhetoric Against Quintilian,” Peter Ramus wants to isolate matters he considers essential to the study of rhetoric—style and delivery—leaving dialectical matters to other disciplines. In “On the Study…
Week 4: “On the Study Methods of Our Time”
by kmontero • • 0 Comments
“On the StudyMethods of Our Time” by Giambattista Vico illustrates the benefits and detriments of the study methods of the author’s time (early 18th century) in comparison to those of the ancients. Vico looks to highlight the advantages and disadvantages of his…
Medieval and Renaissance Class Questions
by MaryAnn Macedo • • 12 Comments
Hey Everyone! Sorry it took me a few days– was working all weekend, but finally got something down. I had plenty of questions after the reading, but I’m honestly more curious to see what you have to say than to…
Socrates on rhetoric
by uzma • • 0 Comments
The Socratic Dialogue is an interesting reading about the definition and use of rhetoric. In my opinion rhetoric is the game of words; an artificer of persuasion that creates belief about just among the masses. The rhetoricians convince men that…
Quintilian
by uzma • • 0 Comments
In my opinion Quintilian’s rhetoric covers three aspects: the theoretical, the educational, and the practical. He agrees on the theory of rhetoric with other rhetoricians “that oratory is the science of speaking well, for it embraces all the virtues, and…
Cicero
by simi dhaliwal • • 0 Comments
I found this in my drafts for some reason it never got published ? “What greater intellectual treat than the brilliant discourse of a perfect scholar?” In Cicero “De Oratore”, Cicero is confident that the power an orator possesses is…
by Shirley Miranda • • 0 Comments
Shirley Miranda Brenes March 4, 2010 On Aristotle, Quintilian, and Cicero Undoubtedly this week’s readings are vast and cover an array of really interesting elements in rhetoric, and although quite different, they all interrelate. I was particularly drawn by the…
Versions of Enthymeme
by lminnis209 • • 0 Comments
I had to write out what enthymeme meant since it was used with the word syllogism. Try saying those two words ten times without stuttering! Reading how they relate to one another was a reading tongue twister, but my impression…